Season 4 Episode Brother's Keeper

Nathan and Peter return to Peter's New York apartment. Nathan is in an existential funk. You can change the voice and change the face, but the fact is he is Sylar underneath it all. His hands have murdered dozens of people. Peter doesn't buy it. Didn't Matt say he forced Sylar out? Nathan can't believe that Matt's capable of exterminating Sylar once and for all. To the rest of the world, he may look like Nathan Petrelli, but who does Peter see? He sees Sylar, right? Nathan dares Peter to tell him he's wrong, but Peter remains silent.

1 of 20 NEXT